How much time will New Yorkers save from the subway signal improvements in the MTA’s Fast Forward plan? According to our new analysis, a single commuter traveling from the Bronx, Queens, or Brooklyn to the Manhattan central business district stands to gain days of their own time back over the course of a year. As state legislators debate how to fund Fast Forward, this analysis shows what’s at stake for their constituents, who will experience shorter wait times, faster trains, and greater reliability.
Our fact sheets show three time savings scenarios for subway commuters. Someone taking the train from Jackson Heights to West 4th Street, for instance, would save 26 minutes a day, which adds up to 110 hours per year. For parents, that could mean saving nearly $2,000 in child care costs. That’s enough time to make breakfast for your kids in the morning or read to them at night. It’s time someone could spend walking her dog in the evening, or fitting in that SoulCycle class. And that’s 110 hours you won’t spend fretting about whether you’ll be late because your train was delayed.
The largest potential source of revenue to fund Fast Forward is congestion pricing. Resistance to congestion pricing is often framed in terms of the impact on car commuters who live outside Manhattan. But there are far more subway commuters living outside Manhattan who’ll save big chunks of time thanks to investments in modern signals than car commuters who’ll pay a congestion fee.
The cumulative time savings for all subway riders adds up to millions of hours per year. In Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie’s district, for instance, the 9,000 riders commuting to the Manhattan CBD will save at least 300,000 hours annually. In State Senator Leroy Comrie’s district in Queens, 25,000 subway commuters would save 838,000 hours each year.
If the Fast Forward plan is fully funded, the MTA plans to resignal substantial portions of every subway line in the city within the next 10 years, much sooner than under the previous 40-year timeline. As our fact sheets demonstrate, benefits for subway riders from funding Fast Forward are immense, and so is the cost of inaction in Albany. We can’t spend another 40 years stuck with slow and unreliable subway service on a typical day, and paralyzing service meltdowns when things go wrong.
For this analysis, travel time savings were calculated by comparing current trip data from the MTA to predicted travel times on lines slated for upgrades under Fast Forward.
The ground has shifted, and the transit system must adapt and change in response -- or else the future for subway and bus riders looks bleak, as do the prospects for the entire New York City region.Read More
Before COVID-19 struck, LA Metro seemed to be turning a corner on bus service with the ambitious network redesign known as NextGen. But the new budget plan signals a return to the days when Metro regularly overlooked the bus riders who make the vast majority of trips on its services.Read More